Prenuptial agreements – also called prenups – can be an extremely useful tool prior to a couple getting married. A prenup is a written contract between spouses that outlines how assets and marital property are divided if they should happen to divorce.
While prenups typically provide protection and clarity, they must be drafted correctly in order to be legally enforced. Under specific circumstances, a New York court can void a prenuptial agreement, leaving parties in a significantly different financial position than they anticipated. This article will discuss reasons why a prenup may be voided, various signs of an unfair prenup, and protecting your rights in divorce.
When Can a Prenup Become Void?
There are many reasons why a prenuptial agreement can be invalid, including:
The prenup was not entered into voluntarily – A valid prenup must be freely entered into by both spouses. If one of the parties was pressured, coerced, or threatened into the agreement, a New York court may invalidate the prenup. Imposing a tight deadline and creating a sense of urgency can be considered duress. Additionally, if one spouse was in a vulnerable state of mind or suffering from a health or mental condition, the court may question the validity of the document.
A spouse did not fully disclose assets – New York law requires both parties to disclose their assets, debts, and income fully and honestly before signing a prenuptial agreement. Hiding assets – including bank accounts, real estate, or investments – or misrepresenting financial information by understating or overstating income can invalidate the agreement.
Unethical or unscrupulous terms – If the terms of the prenup are incredibly unfair, the document can be considered void. This does not apply to cases in which one spouse receives less than the other. The prenup can be void if the agreement is so unjust that it leaves one spouse unable to support themselves and in an incredibly disadvantaged financial position. A New York court will consider the circumstances surrounding the prenup and its overall fairness.
The prenup was not signed on time – The agreement must be signed in a timely manner before the nuptials take place. It also must be notarized and signed by both parties. While New York law doesn’t mandate a specific time period that’s required to sign, it’s generally recommended to sign a prenup well in advance of the marriage – ideally 1-3 months beforehand.
Obtaining a signature fraudulently – If a spouse forges the other party’s signature or obtains their signature by lying or concealing facts, the prenup can be invalidated.
One or both spouses do not have independent legal counsel – Since each spouse has their separate interests at stake, they should be represented by their own separate prenuptial agreement attorney in order to enforce the prenup. While this is not a strict requirement in most states, having separate lawyers ensures that each party understands their rights and obligations under the agreement and that their best interests are well represented.
NY Prenup Legal Requirements
- Both parties must enter into the agreement voluntarily, without coercion or duress.
- The agreement must be in writing and signed by both parties.
- Both parties must provide full and fair disclosure of their financial situation, including assets, debts, and income.
- The agreement must be fair and reasonable at the time that it’s made and at the time of divorce as well.
Signs of an Unfair Prenup
Prenups are a valuable tool that’s used to protect assets, but they can be used unfairly to take advantage of the other spouse as well. An unfair prenup is characterized by coercion or duress to sign the document. A prenup that is one-sided or if one spouse does not have legal representation, the prenup may be deemed to be unfair. Additionally, if a spouse lies about their assets and/or fails to disclose their correct financial situation, the court may invalidate the prenup.
Proving Prenup Invalidity in Court
If a spouse believes that their prenuptial agreement is invalid, they can challenge it, even if it meets the legal requirements. However, they will need appropriate evidence to support the claim of invalidity. The court may need proof of coercion, fraud, incapacity, duress, or a lack of full financial disclosure. Proof may include witness testimony, financial records, evidence of threats, or applicable text messages, and/or medical records.
Protecting Your Rights in Divorce
You have the right to a fair and equitable division of assets if you’ve signed a prenup before you got married. A committed prenuptial agreement lawyer can most likely keep you from making unfortunate decisions that can affect you for many years. Contact us today for a free consultation and we’ll help you navigate New York’s complicated legal system.